One more year, and this would be a 50th anniversary retrospective on the Jeep Cherokee. Instead, on February 28, Stellantis idled Belvidere Assembly in Illinois, the plant where it had built the KL Cherokee since 2017, and effectively ended Cherokee production, so instead of an anniversary, we’ll instead hold a funeral for the SUV.
Or maybe not? Jeep’s official statement only notes that 2023 Jeep Cherokee production ended with the
Belvedere idling, with no mention of the end of the Cherokee nameplate: “We have plans for that important vehicle in that important segment. We will make an announcement on that next-generation vehicle in due course.” Speculation has it that the KL Cherokee’s replacement will be an EV of some sort, which would fit in with the company’s plans to introduce four all-electric SUVs in Europe and North America by the end of 2025, but Jeep has not confirmed or denied that the Cherokee name will return at all. Given Cherokee Nation Principal Chief Chuck Hoskin Jr.’s request to drop the Cherokee name from Jeep products, this move could just be Stellantis taking the most convenient off-ramp for the nameplate.
Whatever the fate of the Cherokee, the news at least gives us the opportunity to reflect on the five generations of the SUV and to debate which is the best iteration.
1974-1983 SJ Cherokee
The long-lived SJ platform with its Brooks Stevens-designed body had already been in production for 11 years when AMC brought it in for a refresh to take the place of the outgoing Jeepster Commando and to compete against Chevrolet’s Blazer and Ford’s Bronco. Starting with the two-door version of the Wagoneer – which hadn’t been in production since 1968 – they added the Gladiator pickup’s “razor” grille and loaded up the option list with alloy wheels, plush interiors, and Jeep’s Quadra-Trac full-time four-wheel-drive system.
As Pat Foster wrote in “Jeep: The History of America’s Greatest Vehicle,” AMC was able to make “a handsome profit because the actual tooling bill had been next to nothing.” It immediately outsold its stablemate Wagoneer and, with the addition of a four-door version of the Cherokee in 1977, sales doubled. The late Seventies fuel crisis, however, showed AMC the folly of relying on its full-size SUVs, with sales cratering to sub-10,000 figures in the early Eighties.
Still, the Cherokee and the rest of the full-size Jeeps have a devoted following today among off-roaders and restorers. Several have even been given the high-end restomod treatment, including the ones that Jeep itself has transformed into Easter Jeep Safari vehicles.
Total Production / Average Production by Year: 153,321 / 15,332
Market Values: On Hemmings.com, prices range from about $20,000 up to $90,000, with an average of $48,000. Classic.com reports a price range of about $9,000 up to $74,000, with an average of about $25,000.
1984-2001 XJ Cherokee
More than just a downsized SUV, the XJ Cherokee represented a complete rethink of the segment. Gone was the body-on-frame construction, replaced by a Uniframe integrated body and frame. Gone were the V-8s, replaced by four-cylinders and V-6s. About the only aspect that carried over to the XJs were the solid front and rear axles.
But, as it turned out, those changes resulted in a far better Cherokee. It proved immediately popular, winning 4×4 of the year awards left and right and selling in massive numbers. Eventually, it became a darling of the off-road crowd due to the ruggedness of its design, the stout parts that AMC fitted to it (particularly the legendary 4.0L straight-six), and the ease with which one could modify it. While the XJ was never built as a convertible, AMC did offer it as a four-door for the suburban set, a two-door for the forest ranger fleets, in right-hand-drive versions for rural postal workers, and even as a compact pickup under the Comanche name.
Just as important to Jeep’s fortunes, the XJ also proved popular overseas, particularly in China where the Beijing Jeep Company – Jeep’s joint venture there – took the basic XJ and ran with it. And back here in the States, it proved the longest-lasting generation of the Cherokee, remaining on the market for a full 18 years with just a single facelift.
Total Production / Average Production by Year: 2,884,172 / 160,232
Market Values: On Hemmings.com, prices range from less than $5,000 up to $37,000, with an average of about $20,000. Classic.com reports a price range of about $3,000 up to about $40,000, with an average of about $12,500.
2002-2007 KJ Liberty
Perhaps it’s not fair to compare the KJ Liberty to its predecessors. After all, while Jeep clearly intended it to be the XJ’s successor, the XJ was a tough act to follow, and Jeep itself conceded as much by adopting the Liberty name for the KJ chassis.
However, Jeep did sell the KJ as the Cherokee in overseas markets, so it counts. And really, it’s not that dissimilar from the XJ. It remained a unit-body SUV with a longitudinal drivetrain, four-wheel drive, and a basic two-box shape. Early renderings even show it as a far more squared-off SUV with definite XJ character before it directly co-opted the 1997 Jeep Dakar’s greenhouse.
On the other hand, the evolution of the Cherokee is emblematic of the evolution of sport-utility vehicles in general – from big pickup-derived brute to more civilized soft-roader – and the KJ continued that evolution with an independent front suspension, a V-6 in place of the 4.0L, much softer lines, and a four-door-only bodystyle. As a result, it’s not nearly as popular with off-roaders or the aftermarket these days, despite the fact that the KJ’s average sales over its six years nearly matched those of the XJ.
Total Production / Average Production by Year: 958,540 / 159,757
Market Values: None are currently for sale on Hemmings.com. Classic.com reports a price range of about $3,500 to $14,000, with an average of about $7,500.
2008-2012 KK Liberty
Another Liberty sold overseas as the Cherokee, the KK was the post-bankruptcy compact SUV that borrowed the XK Commander’s squared-off styling and that shared a platform and body with the Dodge Nitro.
Like its direct predecessor, it rode a unit-body chassis with independent front suspension and a solid rear axle. Only the V-6 remained, in either diesel or gasoline form, though a six-speed manual did remain for customers to order, and Jeep did offer a full cloth roof called the Sky Slider, though so-equipped KKs were rare, even when new.
Unlike its direct predecessor, it sold like a dinghy in the desert. Only the SJ had lower average annual sales, though the SJ was offered well before the SUV boom.
Total Production / Average Production by Year: 302,145 / 60,429
Market Values: Two have sold recently or are currently for sale on Hemmings.com, at $11,250 and $10,998 respectively. But let’s be honest; you can find them all day locally for two grand.
2013-2023 KL Cherokee
As for the outgoing Cherokee, it brought back the indigenous nameplate to the United States, but it also switched to the Chrysler-Fiat Compact Wide platform, which could be found underneath the Dodge Dart and several other FCA vehicles. With a transverse-mounted drivetrain, it switched from the KK’s rear bias to front, with a rear axle that could be disconnected.
Like many other late-Teens Jeeps, it came in a plethora of trim levels, including the Trail Rated Trailhawk, which made many a Jeep enthusiast wonder just what it really takes for a Jeep to earn the Trail Rated badge. The most divisive aspect to the KL, however, were its slim squinty headlamps, which Jeep left in place until a 2019 restyling.
Curiously, though the highly acclaimed Pentastar engine debuted in 2009, the only Cherokee to receive one was the KL, which used a 3.2L version.
Total Production / Average Production by Year: 1,490,309 / 135,483
Market Values: On Hemmings.com, prices range from about $17,000 to $28,000, with an average of about $22,000.
So Which Cherokee Comes Out on Top?
As always, it comes down to a number of factors, doesn’t it? Generational preference, individual tastes, and various purposes all play into which Cherokee could be considered the best. The KJ and the KK do have their adherents, and perhaps over time, as the KL progresses beyond mere used car, some may rediscover it as their off-roader of choice. I mean, people are lifting Ford Festivas and unironically sending them off on trail rides these days, so literally anything is conceivable.
That said, anybody looking at Cherokees more for investment than for play would do well to source an SJ. Those looking for a reliable and capable off-roader can easily find an XJ anywhere in the country. Meanwhile, the KL is probably the best choice to save a buck at the pump.
Which do you prefer?